Few subjects divide dog walkers as sharply as the leash. To some it is a restraint that spoils the whole point of taking a dog into the hills; to others it is the bare minimum of courtesy to wildlife, livestock and other walkers. We have come to think both camps are asking the wrong question. The useful questions are: what do the rules say here, what does this particular landscape need, and is my dog honestly under control without a line? This is how we answer them before every walk.
Where the rules come from
Trail rules for dogs are set at several levels at once, and the strictest one applies. National legislation may require that dogs be under control at all times; regional or municipal by-laws often set specific leash rules in parks and on beaches, sometimes seasonally; and the manager of a particular reserve, forest or trail network can impose stricter conditions still, including a complete ban. The practical consequence is that the rule can change at a gate. A path that allows free-running dogs on farmland can enter a nature reserve where leashes are compulsory and then a national park where dogs are not allowed at all. We read the signs at every boundary and check the managing authority’s website before a trip, because the poster at the car park is often the only notice we will see.
National parks, in general terms
Rules vary enormously between countries, and even between parks in the same country, but a few broad patterns hold. In the national parks of the United States, dogs are typically required to be on a leash no longer than about two metres, and in many parks they are restricted to roads, campgrounds and a small number of paved or developed trails, with the backcountry closed to them entirely. Canadian national parks generally allow leashed dogs on most trails but close specific areas to them, especially where wildlife conflicts are common. Across much of Europe the picture is mixed: some parks permit leashed dogs on marked paths, some impose seasonal leash requirements during breeding or grazing periods, and core zones of many reserves exclude dogs altogether. Several countries in the southern hemisphere prohibit dogs in national parks almost without exception, to protect ground-dwelling native species that evolved without mammalian predators.
Fines for breaking these rules are real, but the more serious consequence is the harm done. A dog that chases a nesting bird off its eggs on a cold morning may have ended that brood, whether or not anyone saw it.
What off-leash really requires
Where free running is allowed, the standard in most jurisdictions is that the dog must be under effective control, and that phrase has a fairly precise meaning. It means the dog stays within sight, returns immediately to a single call even with a deer, a hare or another dog in view, and can be leashed at once when someone or something appears on the trail. A dog that comes back eventually, after a chase, is not under control; it has simply finished chasing. We test our own dogs honestly on this, in low-distraction places first, and we keep the leash on until the recall is reliable against the specific temptations of the area we are walking in. That is a training project measured in months, and it is worth every one of them.
When off-leash is unfair to wildlife
Even a dog that never catches anything causes harm by being a predator on the move. Wild animals do not know that the dog is friendly; they see a canid and respond with flight, which costs energy they may not have. The situations where we keep the leash on regardless of the rules are these:
- Spring and early summer, when ground-nesting birds such as plovers, curlews and grouse sit tight on eggs and chicks, and a dog quartering through heather or dunes flushes them and exposes the nest.
- Late winter, when deer, chamois and other ungulates are at the low point of their reserves and a single chase through deep snow can be fatal even if the dog never gets close.
- Alpine pastures and moorland in the grazing season, where sheep, cattle and the large guardian dogs that protect them are on the hill and a loose dog can be injured or cause a stampede.
- Any area of bear, wolf or wild boar habitat, where a dog that runs ahead may return with something dangerous following it.
- Wetlands, beaches and estuaries used by roosting or migrating waterfowl and waders, where a single disturbance moves hundreds of birds.
A long line of five to ten metres gives a dog most of the freedom of off-leash walking while keeping the wildlife safe, and it is what we use on nearly every open-country walk.
Livestock and the law
In most rural jurisdictions a dog that worries livestock, which includes chasing as well as attacking, exposes the owner to fines and civil liability, and a farmer may be entitled to shoot a dog caught in the act. The rule we follow is to leash the dog on entering any field with animals in it, walk calmly around the edge of the flock rather than through it, and, if cattle approach and become aggressive, to drop the leash and let the dog run, since the cattle are almost always reacting to the dog and not to us. The one situation in which a dog should be let go is that one.
Courtesy on the shared trail
Finally there are the people. Not everyone likes dogs, some are frightened of them, and a trail runner or a horse rider surprised by a loose dog around a blind bend has no way of knowing it is harmless. Our habit is to call the dog to heel and step off the trail whenever we meet anyone, to leash up in advance on narrow or busy sections, and to carry the bags out rather than leaving them decorated beside the path. A dog that waits calmly on the verge while a family passes does more for the future of dog access to the hills than any argument ever will. The rules are the floor; how we behave above the floor is what decides whether the next generation of dog walkers is welcome on the same trails.
Read next: Can Dogs Walk in Snow Without Shoes? What Paws Can Handle